Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tory M.'s avatar

“And, tragically, this means that the very term of “the Left” has become tarnished by progressivism, reduced to a caricature of unseriousness held with serious conviction.”

Brilliant, Alan! This is a wonderful articulation of the problem.

Expand full comment
Paul Steger's avatar

A very interesting read! Thank you :-)

I think another very interesting dimension along this divide between class and identity becomes very apparent is international trade. There is plenty of sound economic (empirical) research that trade liberalization (ironically often implemented by "leftist" parties), whilst growing the pie nationally and benefitting the hubs of progressivism, has had a devastating impact on certain local economies (you mentioned the rust belt). And even if you believe that free trade is good overall, you could still have softened the blow by implementing social and economic programs to aid the hardest hit. Doing so could have prevented the assaults on democracy, we have seen in the last couple of years.. But obviously those are questions of a too nitty-gritty and technical nature for progressive warriors and would help people you actually deplore 🥴

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts